Strictly Come Dancing's refreshed hosting line-up has survived its first month on air, but the verdict from viewers and critics is still far from unanimous. Emma Willis, Johannes Radebe and Josh Widdicombe have begun to find their rhythm, yet the BBC's flagship Saturday-night show remains noticeably different after the departure of Tess Daly and Claudia Winkleman.

Strictly Come Dancing's new presenting trio faces a challenging start

The change was always going to be a daunting one. Replacing a much-loved presenting partnership on one of television's biggest entertainment programmes was never likely to be a waltz in the park. Making the transition even more complicated, the show moved from two presenters to three, with each member of the new team given a distinct role.

Willis has brought a polished, calm presence to the live programme, while former professional dancer Radebe has added energy, warmth and technical knowledge. Widdicombe, the mischievous comedian of the group, is the unexpected wildcard. Unlike his co-hosts, he was not previously associated with the dance world or with presenting a major prime-time live show.

Willis and Widdicombe appear together during the live broadcasts, where his job is to provide humour around the dances and keep the atmosphere lively before and after each performance. The idea sounds straightforward, but critics have found the execution uneven. Some of his jokes have landed, while other moments have made the show feel hurried and slightly uncomfortable.

Radebe has taken over the mezzanine area previously occupied by Winkleman. From there, he speaks to the celebrities after they leave the dance floor, when nerves are still high and emotions are often close to the surface. His role allows him to combine his experience as a dancer with the reassuring manner of a supportive interviewer.

Josh Widdicombe faces harsh criticism after Strictly debut

The first reactions were brutal. After the trio made their debut in September, Carol Midgley described them as television's most awkward ménage à trois. Chris Bennion called the new arrangement an utter disaster and labelled it a mess, a muddle and a confusing pudding.

Widdicombe attracted the sharpest criticism. Sasha Morris said he seemed like an awkward spare part and compared him with the work experience boy. Isobel Lewis went even further, describing him as a problem the programme needed to solve. Those early judgments made it clear that the comedian had a particularly difficult mountain to climb.

Critics see improvement but question Widdicombe's presenting style

Lewis now believes the situation has improved, even though she does not think every problem has disappeared. In her view, Widdicombe sometimes behaves too much like a comedian and not enough like a presenter. His instinct is to chase the laugh, but live television leaves very little space for a performer to improvise safely.

She has noticed, however, that he seems more comfortable when working with Willis on the scripted introductions. When the pair deliver their lines from the autocue before each act, they appear more confident and the partnership feels more natural. The trouble begins when Widdicombe tries to break away from the structure and become spontaneous.

The timing is especially unforgiving. The presenters may have only around 20 seconds with each judge, meaning every interruption, joke and reaction has to fit into a tightly controlled window. Lewis says that this can make Widdicombe appear sloppy or as though he is constantly jumping in. It may even look as if he is trying to steal attention or make sure he gets the final laugh, although she does not believe he is deliberately behaving selfishly.

Instead, she sees it as the automatic impulse of a comedian who is used to responding quickly and making the most of a live moment. The same instinct that makes him funny in one setting can make him seem disruptive in another. Lewis also argues that it is unfair to place the entire burden of the show's early awkwardness on him.

As the weeks have passed, online reaction has begun to shift, with some fans appearing to warm to him. Lewis says that the first response to a major change is often a knee-jerk declaration that viewers do not like it. Familiarity, she suggests, may be giving the new hosts room to settle before the audience reaches a final judgment.

Emma Willis and Josh Widdicombe urged to develop more natural chemistry

Caroline Frost also believes the trio are slowly finding their feet. She accepts that the opening episodes contained several bumps in the road, but says the presenters now seem to be relaxing into their new responsibilities. The change is not dramatic or complete, yet the early stiffness has begun to ease.

Frost would like to see Willis and Widdicombe become more spontaneous rather than more dependent on prepared material. Their double act has visibly leaned on scripts and planned gags, which is understandable given the scale of the production. A live show must stay on schedule, and the presenters have to keep track of judges, dancers, music, camera cues and the many other demands unfolding around them.

Even so, Frost believes the strongest presenters can handle those pressures while still appearing free and natural. She describes Widdicombe as very likeable and recognises that he is a very funny man. Her hope is that he will no longer seem handcuffed to the script and will be allowed to show more of the instinctive humour that made him successful elsewhere.

Could Strictly Come Dancing change its presenters' roles?

Frost has also floated a possible change to the presenters' duties. Rather than keeping Radebe in the post-dance interview area, she suggests that Widdicombe could move upstairs while Radebe takes on a broader role across the rehearsal rooms. That would allow the former professional dancer to use his strongest asset: the ability to explain what is happening technically without losing the warmth that makes contestants feel comfortable.

She imagines Radebe acting as a kind of talent pundit, offering viewers a bridge between the performance they see on the dance floor and the difficult work taking place behind it. He could become a middleman between the technical details of training and the emotional reality of the celebrities preparing for each routine.

Before the series began, there had been suggestions that Radebe might work as a roving reporter. Widdicombe had also described the trio's responsibilities as fluid, comparing the arrangement with total football and saying they would be moving everywhere. In practice, some parts of the format remain flexible, particularly during the Sunday result show, but the main roles have appeared much more fixed than that early description suggested.

Johannes Radebe wins praise for replacing Claudia Winkleman

Radebe's presence in Winkleman's former territory has nonetheless won over a section of the audience. Flo Sayers, co-host of the Strictly on the Sofa podcast, says JoJo has been brilliant in what she jokingly calls the Claudatorium, although she is unsure what the area should be called now.

For Sayers, Radebe provides a link to the earlier identity of Strictly while still giving the programme something new. She likes that he is not trying to imitate Winkleman. Instead of making comedy the centre of every exchange, he comes across as a supportive friend for contestants who have just finished dancing and may be feeling particularly vulnerable.

His fashion has also become part of the weekly attraction. Sayers says his outfits have been amazing and admits she is excited to see what he wears next. That enthusiasm reflects one of the clearest areas in which Radebe has already made the role his own rather than simply stepping into someone else's shadow.

Strictly Come Dancing ratings fall amid hosting changes

The new line-up has arrived during a period of lower ratings. Around six million people have been watching each week this year, approximately one million fewer than before. Sayers is not convinced that the change in hosts is responsible for the decline, and she believes it is too soon to draw a firm connection between the viewing figures and the new presenting arrangement.

Overall, she thinks all three presenters are adjusting to the demands of the series. That view is shared by Dr Karen Wood, an associate professor at Coventry University's Centre for Dance Research, who says the trio now feel considerably more settled than they did at the beginning.

Dance expert praises Johannes Radebe and Emma Willis

Wood believes Radebe has made a beautiful transition from professional dancer to host. He brings his unmistakable flamboyance, but he can also discuss technical details while remaining supportive towards both the professional dancers and the celebrity contestants. In her view, the combination suits the mezzanine role extremely well, and she is equally impressed by his marvellous outfits.

She also praises Willis, saying the experienced presenter holds her own both alongside Widdicombe and when she is working without him. Her confidence is visible, Wood believes, because she has the experience to manage the demands of live television without allowing the pressure to overwhelm her.

Widdicombe's contribution remains the most debated. His humour has attracted criticism, but Wood felt that last week marked an important turning point. For the first time, she found herself thinking that he and Willis were genuinely funny together. That does not erase the earlier doubts, but it suggests that the relationship between the pair may be developing in front of the audience.

Can Strictly's new hosts win over viewers as the series continues?

Wood's conclusion is cautiously positive: the hosts are beginning to discover their stride and their rhythm, and that development should continue. In the same way that the celebrity contestants become more confident as the competition progresses, the presenters may also improve through repetition, familiarity and a better understanding of one another.

There is one important difference. The dancers can be eliminated if the public and judges decide they have not done enough, while the hosts cannot be voted off when a joke falls flat or a transition feels awkward. For now, Emma Willis, Johannes Radebe and Josh Widdicombe remain in place, with viewers watching closely to see whether this unusual trio can turn an uncertain opening into a confident finish.

The next episode of Strictly Come Dancing airs on BBC One at 18:30 BST on Saturday.