A piece of London’s restaurant history has been handed over to the National Trust in a remarkable £11 million gift.
London's oldest restaurant Rules donated to National Trust in £11 million deal
The freehold of 34-35 Maiden Lane, in the heart of Covent Garden, has been donated to the charity by J-P Mayhew, the owner of Rules for the past 40 years. The building has been home to the celebrated restaurant since 1798, making it one of the capital’s most enduring places to eat and one of its most atmospheric survivors.
The donation is designed to protect far more than the walls of the historic property. It also includes visitor books, old menus, caricatures, photographs, stained glass and signs, preserving the objects that help tell the story of the people who passed through Rules over more than two centuries. The annual rent from the restaurant’s continuing business will also go towards conservation work, allowing the building to be cared for year after year.
Rules restaurant's 225-year history in Covent Garden
Rules began life as an oyster bar at the end of the 18th century. Since then, it has outlasted empires, survived the Blitz and escaped plans to replace the surrounding area with a dual carriageway. Through all those changes, its doors remained open and its dining rooms continued to attract generations of famous guests.
Charles Dickens and Charlie Chaplin were among the figures associated with the restaurant. Edward VII also visited, using the establishment as a meeting place with his mistresses. Later diners included Liza Minnelli, David Bowie, Harrison Ford and Madonna, adding more layers to a history already crowded with celebrated names.
John Betjeman and Graham Greene's literary connections to Rules
The building’s rooms carry the names of two important literary figures: poet John Betjeman and writer Graham Greene. Betjeman delivered an impassioned defence of Rules when Maiden Lane faced the threat of redevelopment. His appeal focused not only on the paintings, sculptures, stained glass and red plush seats, but also on what he called the restaurant’s “invisible atmosphere”.
Greene had birthday meals at Rules and featured the restaurant in his novel The End Of The Affair. Those connections remain part of the building’s character, alongside the preserved interiors, long-running traditions and countless stories held within its rooms.
National Trust to preserve Rules as a working historic restaurant
The National Trust has described Rules as a rare example of living heritage. Unlike a building preserved only as a museum, 34-35 Maiden Lane still performs the same purpose for which it became famous: it remains a working restaurant. The original use of the building has survived alongside its historic structure, with more than two centuries of continuous restaurant operation.
Since the 19th century, Rules has maintained a tradition of English “country house” cuisine. Even now, the menu includes treacle sponge, a small but telling detail that reflects the restaurant’s ability to carry old customs into the present without closing its doors to modern life.
National Trust director Hilary McGrady welcomes historic donation
Hilary McGrady, director-general of the National Trust, called the property an outstanding piece of living history. She highlighted its corners where kings dined and writers and politicians plotted, as well as the traditions that remained alive through wars and upheaval.
McGrady said Rules had “defied the odds” by still standing with its doors open and treacle sponge on the menu. She said Mr Mayhew’s generosity, together with the care he had given the restaurant over many decades, meant its future could now be measured in generations rather than years.
She added that the gift would keep one of London’s great living institutions within the city’s cultural life, with its stories, traditions and character protected intact.
J-P Mayhew explains decision to donate Rules to National Trust
For Mayhew, the decision was a response to the same appeal Betjeman made when the restaurant’s future was threatened in 1971 by the Greater London Council’s plans to turn the Strand into a dual carriageway. Mayhew said few restaurants anywhere had endured the test of time like Rules, which had survived redevelopment plans, changing tastes and the Blitz through hard work and extraordinary luck.
He said Betjeman had defended not only the visible features of the restaurant, but also its “invisible atmosphere”. By giving the property to the National Trust, Mayhew said he was answering that appeal and ensuring that the bricks and mortar, famous interior and atmosphere would all be protected.
Mayhew also expressed his gratitude to the Trust for believing in the idea and taking responsibility for a building containing two centuries of stories. His hope is that people will continue to enjoy those stories long into the future.
Rules restaurant to continue operating under National Trust ownership
Rules’ proprietor, Ricky McMenemy, has worked at the restaurant for 35 years and will become a commercial tenant of the National Trust. He welcomed the arrangement, saying it gave the independent business security and peace of mind that its home would be in good hands and protected going forward.
McMenemy said the restaurant had already developed a very amicable working relationship with the Trust and looked forward to another two centuries in the building it calls home.
Rules becomes National Trust's first operating historic restaurant
The National Trust already cares for 39 historic pubs that continue to operate, including the George Inn in Southwark and the Crown Bar in Belfast. However, 34-35 Maiden Lane will be the first building in the charity’s care to house an historic restaurant that is still in operation.
For Rules, the change brings a new guardian without ending the life that made the building important in the first place. The dining rooms, preserved details, familiar dishes and accumulated memories will remain tied to a working restaurant, keeping London’s oldest restaurant alive rather than frozen in the past.
